Key Lime Coolers

  • Key Lime Coolers 16oz Bag
    Key Lime Coolers 16oz Bag
  • $17.50
The perfect slice of key lime pie is the inspiration behind this temptingly sweet and tart bite-sized cooler cookie. Key lime juice and a Byrd Cookie Company exclusive citrus powdered sugar create a pleasant pucker that will whisk you away to the Florida Keys. Our Key Lime Coolers are a local Savannah and Byrd staff favorite. For a very special treat, chill your Key Lime Coolers for a cool citrus sensation!

  • NASFT Dessert of the Year Winner
  • Our Best Seller
Nutrition Information
Shop Our



Write a review
Get Ready to Be Blown Away...
Apr 9, 2019  |  By Linda B.
Get ready to be blown away by the awesomeness of these melt-in-your-mouth cookies. I've realized that I usually eat about 1/4 of a bag the day it arrives (truly). Buyer Beware: You will be hooked when once you try Byrd's Key Lime cookies (they're that great)!!

Key lime
Jul 22, 2019  |  By Joyce Vereen

Nov 17, 2019  |  By Judy Hayes
My husband and I were here last weekend for our 25th anniversary and stopped into Byrd's just to look around, but walked out with 4 bags of cookies!!!! I got the Key lime, melt-in-your-mouth cookies and he got the peanut butter chocolate chip. I can't say enough about how wonderful these little bites of sweetness are in your mouth!! If you are a cookie lover, this is your dream stop!!!

Jan 10, 2020  |  By Janelle
I do not like key lime. That said I loved these cookies. They're light and not too sweet. They were more tart than I was expecting, I think I that's why I love them.

Feb 3, 2020  |  By Emma
I was visiting Charleston in January, and decided to give these a try. I will never look at cookies the same. Chocolate chip used to be my favorite, but these are BY FAR the best cookies I've ever had. I will definitely find some way to get these again. They're SO addicting, I ate them all in a day in a half!

Florida Girl
Aug 18, 2020  |  By Lil G
Happened upon the shop in Gatlinburg and tried a sample. HOOKED. Now I'll have to order on line. These are the best!

The Best cookies
Sep 23, 2020  |  By Debra Blackwell
The Key Lime Peach And Lemon are so good! They have wonderful flavor !

Nov 29, 2020  |  By Tas Cee
These were perfect....the best flavor in one bite...not to strong just right! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

Jan 6, 2021  |  By Ashley W
It's like biting into a key lime pie. So yummy. Ate the whole bag in an hour.

Apr 14, 2021  |  By Penny Comer
These are the best cookies ever. I brought my husband some home from Savannah recently and he LOVED them.

Key Lime Blessings
Apr 24, 2021  |  By Shalon Hannah
To know that this company has been around since 1924 is a blessing. I forever grateful my Key Lime Coolers. Each cookie is a different experience! Supporting you from TN!

Key Lime Coolers
Jun 1, 2021  |  By Rosella Cooper
I have fallen in love all over again!!!! Trying to ration the bag but I don't know how I will be able to do it.

The BEST Iv'e ever tasted !!!
Sep 4, 2021  |  By Brad Reid
While on vacation in Tennessee , my son bought these "Key lime coolers " for me . These are The BEST Iv'e EVER TASTED , KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK !! :) Thank You

Jul 7, 2022  |  By Jess23
Yummiest cookies & most refreshing cookie I have ever put in my mouth! You can't go wrong...unless you don't treat yourself to these little bites of heaven!

Sep 7, 2022  |  By Jo Kinsey
My friend brought Key Lime Cooler cookies back from Tennessee. These cookies are gluten-free and absolutely delicious!!! They are now my favorite cookies! Thank you. I'll definitely be ordering more.

Sep 7, 2022  |  By Jo Kinsey
My friend brought Key Lime Cooler cookies back from Tennessee. These cookies are gluten-free and absolutely delicious!!! They are now my favorite cookies! Thank you. I'll definitely be ordering more.

Oct 27, 2022  |  By Monica Loudermilk
I tried one of these little cookies recently in Pigeon Forge and OMG. These little cookies have a BIG taste. THEY ARE DELICIOUS. I wish I had bought some

Key lime cookies
Jan 13, 2023  |  By Diane
We stopped in here and bought 3 different kinds of cookies ! But the key lime cookies were fabulous

The VERY best!
Apr 2, 2023  |  By Nancy A
Light, refreshing, these are the very best cookies you will eat! Not too sweet, just right! A buttery, shortbread cookie with a kiss of key lime!

A wonderful gift!
May 13, 2023  |  By Sharon
My friend brought me a gift of your cookies upon returning from Savannah. I don't really like key lime, but your key lime cookies sure changed my mind!! They are bursting with flavor and light and crispy. I am a fan of the key lime, and the Georgia peach cookies are outstanding also. Loved my gift of cookies!!

Our new favorite cookies
Jul 8, 2023  |  By Stephanie
We sampled the cooler cookies while in Gatlinburg and if I'm being honest, I went back for more samples until we finally just accepted our fate and purchased 4 bags. 2 key lime (tastes just like my homemade key lime pie without all of the work), one lemon, and one peach. I can almost guarantee a divorce is coming because we will fight over these bags because they are that AMAZING! Do yourself a favor and just buy these.

Aug 5, 2023  |  By Edward Lupo

Aug 5, 2023  |  By Edward Lupo

Sep 8, 2023  |  By Shiloh
Please do yourself a favor and DO NOT try these, or else! My mom, daughter, and sister went to visit my sisters boyfriend whom actually lives in the house where this company started in Savannah, Georgia. They, of course, had to go check out the Byrd Cookie Company store. My family knows how much I love key lime pie- so my mom decided to bring me back some of these key lime cookies. First of all, I ate two packs of these cookies in one day. Second, I have never had a craving for something before it was even gone. Finally, FINALLY. Y'ALL!! I live 1,200 miles away from this cookie store. I'm going to have to wait for these cookies to be delivered before I can stop my mouth from watering because I cannot stop thinking about how amazing these cookies are. So, if you plan to try these cookies -or take some back home. Make sure you've got enough to never run out so you're not finding yourself in this torturous mess. Believe me, once to try one - you'll never be able to get enough.

Sign Up for Sweet Offers
Facebook Instagram Pinerest